Our policies
  1. Home
  2. The Utility Belt
  3. Blog
Behind the Cape

Before You Hire a Marketing Agency, Ask Why It Exists

Written by Alfred3 min read

A cosy front room at night: a laptop glowing on a table by the window next to a lamp and a mug of tea, an armchair with a knitted blanket beside a small fire, and a quiet street of terraced houses outside.

Built with the help of AI, edited by humans. Facts read on 18 November 2026. How this post was checked.

Every agency will tell you what it does. Far fewer will tell you why it exists. The second answer tells you much more about how you'll be treated when something goes wrong.

The short answer

Before you sign with any marketing agency, ask who started it and why. A good answer is specific, and usually a bit personal. A brochure answer, all disruption and innovation, tells you nothing at all.

Simon answered that question for My Digital Hero in a film of just over two minutes. Here it is.

Why My Digital Hero exists

It didn't start with a dream or a business plan. In Simon's own words: "I started it because my family needed me and I needed to earn a living at the same time."

When his dad died, Simon became his mum's carer. A normal nine to five was out. He couldn't commute, and he couldn't sit in an office. He needed to earn a living from home, around someone else's needs.

So he started doing marketing for small businesses. One client. Then two. Then someone referred someone, who referred someone else. Slowly, very slowly, it became a real business.

A long street of terraced houses at night. One window glows in the nearest house, and further along more and more windows are lit until the far end of the street is full of warm light.

Why that matters to you

Simon is clear in the film that he doesn't tell the story for sympathy. He tells it because it explains the way the agency works. Three things come straight out of it.

  1. Care. "We care about the people we work with because I know what it feels like when someone does not care."
  2. Honesty. As Simon puts it, "life is too short to pretend". So the monthly report tells you the bad news as well as the good.
  3. Doing it properly. The agency's name is on everything that goes out the door. That tends to focus the mind.

Knowing what you're not good at

There's a line in the film worth borrowing for your own agency interviews. Simon brought in Jared, the team's paid ads specialist, because, in his words, "I am honest enough to know that Google Ads is not my strength".

Every agency has weak spots. The good ones know where theirs are, and hire around them. The ones to worry about claim to be brilliant at everything.

It's the same with the rest of the team. Oliver was hired to make the agency sound like humans instead of a brochure. Matthew, now the technical lead, because Simon reckons he's the most talented developer he's ever met.

Five questions to ask any agency before you sign

  1. Who started it, and why? Listen for something real.
  2. Who will I actually talk to? A name and a phone number, or a ticket system?
  3. What aren't you good at? If the answer is "nothing", keep walking.
  4. Who does the work? Ask to see the team. Real names, real faces.
  5. Will you tell me if we're not the right fit? An agency that will say no is one you can believe when it says yes.

Here are our answers, if you'd like to hold them up against everyone else's. Simon is the one you'd talk to. The team is on the site, faces and all. And on the Hero+ page Simon puts it plainly: "If we're not the right fit, I'll say so."

How the film ends

Simon finishes like this: "If you are looking for an agency that was started by someone who had no choice but to make it work, you have found one."

The longer version of his story, including the business that failed first, is on Meet Simon. Or you can book half an hour and ask him question one yourself.

How this post was checked

Facts read on 18 November 2026. Every fact in this post comes from one of these pages.

  1. Capes Off: Why I Left My Job to Start a Marketing Agency (the film and its transcript). Every quote from Simon in this post
  2. Hero+, My Digital Hero. "If we're not the right fit, I'll say so."
  3. Home page, My Digital Hero. The monthly report, good news and bad; Jared's job
  4. The team, My Digital Hero. Matthew is the technical lead
  5. Meet Simon, My Digital Hero. The business that failed first

AlfredBuilt with the help of AI, edited by humans.

What to read next

All posts

Alfred, the My Digital Hero robot, waving

Notes from Simon

Marketing emails you will actually open.

Coming to your inbox

How AI actually works (with the help of a lasagne)

One short note every week or two. Two minutes to read. No jargon.

Unsubscribe in one click, any time. Our policies

You are in.

Keep an eye on your inbox. The first note is a short hello from me. Simon